Versions Compared

Key

  • This line was added.
  • This line was removed.
  • Formatting was changed.

...

Sketch

Storyboard

Learnability

Efficiency

Safety

Image Removed Image Added

Vincent starts by creating a new trip. He enters in the destination
with a textbox that has autocomplete with locations. Since he will
be flying to Europe, he picks the plane icon, along with the male
 symbol. He then selects the 12 days he will be there using the
calendar module that appears as he clicks the date.

Pros

- Easy to learn because there are simple icons that the user
sees which immediately describe what the icon represents
without unnecessary words (aka, picture of airplane = travel
there by plane)

Cons  

- Lack of text may be slightly longer for user to figure out whats 
going on

Pros  

- Autocomplete provides efficiency
- Tapping on icons to select is simple and efficient

Cons 
Pros 

- Allows the user to reselect icons if the wrong one is
chosen 
- Allow user to reinput destinations

Cons

- After hit the "go" button, user cannot edit travel
information from screen, but instead has to delete the
vacation and make a new one

After he hits go, a selection of items are selected and automatically
placed in his backpack. However, because he is a hat-enthusiast, he
decides to bring along 12 hats with him, increasing the weight of his
backpack, and now notices that a luggage symbol has appeared,
suggesting that bringing just a backpack may no longer be appropriate.

Pros 

- Easy metaphor: items can be dragged into container, just like
real packing- Container changes based on # of items making it
easy for the user to see how much stuff they could fit into a
main menu because at the top of the screen but may be
difficult to pick which one is the category you want (example:
what does the "tie" icon represent, accessories or formal wear?)

Cons
Pros  

- Drag and drop provides efficiency

Cons

- Adding/deleting items may take longer than necessary

Pros  

- Adding/deleting items may take longer than necessary

Cons

- Not easy to delete/add item because you have to open backpack

 

Once he is satisfied, he clicks the checklist tab, and he begins to
pack, checking off the items as he goes.

Pros  

- User has most likely encountered a checklist before, so
easy to use this one 

Cons

- Doesn't allow user to add any items, so doesn't support
some functionality of normal checklists

Pros  

- Simple checklist, user can find all items in this checklist

Cons

- If user is looking for a specific item, has to look through
entire list
- Difficult organization, no search

Pros  

- User can delete items or uncheck items they don't want

Cons

- No way to recover an item if a user deletes it

Before he leaves, he clicks the trip information tab, and he
remembers that bringing a camera could be a good idea
as there may be times for sightseeing.

Pros  

- Simple text page, nothing new to learn

Cons

- User doesn't know what to do if they want more information

Pros  

- All information in one location

Cons

- User may want too see only packing tips, must scroll to
the top to see them

Pros  

- User can easily navigate to and away from this page

Cons

...